Airbnb Bed-Making Guide: Duvet Cover, Three-Sheet, or Comforter? Pros & Cons Explained

When you’re setting up a short-term rental, one of the details that makes a big impression, both in photos and in guest satisfaction, is the bed. A well-made, clean, and comfortable bed is a hallmark of a quality stay. But how you make that bed behind the scenes is just as important, especially when it comes to turnover efficiency, cleanliness, and durability.

There are three common methods hosts use: the duvet cover, the three-sheet method, and the comforter/quilt approach. Below, we’ll break down the pros and cons of each so you can choose the best one for your short-term rental.

When you interact with kp_bnb and click on affiliate links, you’re supporting a small creator, and I’m truly grateful. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

1. Duvet Cover

A duvet cover encases a fluffy insert, similar to a pillowcase over a pillow. It’s popular in Europe and increasingly common in U.S. short-term rentals. We LOVE this hypoallergenic all-season down alternative duvet insert. We actually use it in our home, as well. On the insert we use a Zipper Closure & 2 Pillow Shams Duvet Cover. The zipper closure is so much easier than messing around with time consuming buttons or snaps. We don’t use the shams, since the pillows on the bed just have pillow cases that match the sheets.

Pros:

• Highly Sanitary – The cover can be laundered between every guest, giving peace of mind that all top bedding is freshly cleaned.
• Luxurious Look – Duvets photograph beautifully and give the bed a plush, hotel-style appearance.
• Storage-Friendly – Duvet covers and inserts fold easily and take up less shelf space than bulky comforters.

Cons:

• Time-Consuming to Change – Removing and inserting the duvet insert can be a frustrating and time-intensive task, especially for large beds or when under time pressure during turnovers.
• Wrinkling – Cotton or linen duvet covers often wrinkle in the wash, requiring extra effort (or a wrinkle-release spray) to look crisp.
• Confusing for Some Guests – Guests unfamiliar with duvet covers may mistake them for unwashed comforters if they’re not smooth or tucked properly.

2. Three-Sheet Method

This method uses a fitted sheet, a flat sheet, a blanket, and then a second flat sheet on top of the blanket. It’s often used by hotels.

Pros:

• Fully Washable – Every layer touching the guest is laundered between stays, ensuring hygiene.
• No Inserts to Wrestle – Easier and faster to make than a duvet system during turnovers.
• Professional Look – When done well, it presents a crisp, clean look with sharp corners and hospital-style tucks.

Cons:

• More Linens to Manage – Requires more laundry per bed and more folding/storage time.
• Blanket Visibility – Blankets may be thin, unattractive, or not photo-ready unless layered carefully.
• Guest Confusion – Some guests may disassemble the layers or dislike the tucked-in feel.

This Fleece Microplush Blanket – Lightweight Throw for Bed washes beautifully, dries quickly, and comes in many color options to fit your STR’s decor. Buy a couple extras for use on the couch, too!

3. Comforter or Quilt

This involves placing a decorative comforter or quilt on top of the flat sheet, without a cover or second sheet. This Ultra Soft Lightweight All-Season Comforter is a great option, and the texture elevates the overall look and feel. Lots of colors available!

Pros:

• Fastest Turnover – Super quick to throw over a bed, especially helpful for same-day turnovers.
• Simple for Guests – There are no mysteries, just a classic comforter or quilt on top.
• Visually Appealing – Especially when styled with decorative pillows and throws.

Cons:

• Less Hygienic – Unless you wash the comforter between every guest (which is often impractical), it may not feel fully clean to discerning guests.
• Bulky to Store and Wash – Comforters are thick and take up space in storage and in the washer/dryer.
• Fades with Frequent Washing – If you do wash them regularly, they may wear out quickly.

So Which One Is Best for You?

For high-end rentals, the duvet cover method might be worth the effort for the luxurious feel and cleanliness.
For fast turnovers, the three-sheet method can save time while still being hygienic.
For budget listings or minimal laundry, a quilt or comforter might suffice, but be ready to replace them more frequently.

Ultimately, your choice depends on the scale of your operations, your turnover schedule, and your priorities between guest comfort and operational efficiency. Additionally, how is access to a washer and dryer? Are they large enough to fit a comforter or quilt? Do you need to ensure there are always clean backups?

Pro Tip: Whichever method you choose, consistency matters. Make sure your cleaners or turnover team are trained to make beds the same way every time, and always use freshly laundered layers that look crisp in photos and feel clean to guests.